Does Sunscreen Cause Cancer? Myths and Facts about Sunscreen and Cancer

Sunscreen is often scrutinized for concerns regarding its safety, with some questioning its potential link to cancer. The myth that sunscreen causes cancer has led to confusion, but the real risk lies in unprotected sun exposure, which contributes to over 99,000 new cases of melanoma annually in the United States (American Cancer Society, 2024). Sunscreen plays a crucial role in preventing skin cancer by effectively blocking harmful UV rays. Understanding the science behind sunscreen’s ingredients and their safety is essential for making informed decisions about sun protection. This article explores the facts, debunking the misconception that sunscreen causes cancer and providing clarity on its role in safeguarding skin health.

The highest resolution image of the Sun’s surface ever taken. In this picture, we can see features as small as 30km (18 miles) in size for the first time ever. Credit: NSO/AURA/NSF

Does Sunscreen Cause Cancer?

Concerns regarding sunscreen ingredients, particularly oxybenzone and benzene, have gained significant attention due to potential health and environmental risks. Oxybenzone, a common chemical UV filter in sunscreens, has raised concerns due to its potential environmental and human health impacts. Regarding its environmental impact, oxybenzone has been linked to coral bleaching by inducing DNA damage, hormonal disruption, and oxidative stress in corals. This has led to bans on its use in some regions, such as Hawaii and Key West. Susie Suh Int J Dermatol 2024.

In terms of human health concerns, oxybenzone is absorbed systemically, but studies have shown mixed results regarding its effects. It has been associated with dermal allergic reactions and endocrine disruption, though evidence linking it to adverse health outcomes remains inconclusive. Some studies have found no impact on fertility or reproductive hormone levels but have suggested potential effects on thyroid hormone and pubertal timing. Talia Thomas Frontier in Marine Science 2024.

Benzene, a known carcinogen, has been detected in some sunscreen products as a contaminant. Benzene exposure is linked to blood cancers and other health risks. The FDA restricts benzene in pharmaceuticals to 2 parts per million (ppm) when its use is unavoidable but advises avoiding it in other cases. Recent screenings have identified benzene in numerous sunscreen and after-sun care products, raising consumer safety concerns. While the FDA regulates sunscreens as drug products and requires them to meet safety standards, benzene contamination highlights the need for stricter quality control measures. Amber Hudspeth EPH Publishing  2022.

Sunscreens undergo safety testing through various methods, including systemic absorption studies and toxicological assessments. Studies have shown that oxybenzone and other UV filters are absorbed into the bloodstream after application, raising questions about their long-term safety. Regulatory bodies like the FDA require sunscreens to meet specific safety standards, but ongoing research is necessary to fully understand the health impacts of these ingredients.

In summary, while oxybenzone and benzene raise concerns, the evidence on their health effects is mixed. Regulatory positions emphasize the importance of careful monitoring and testing to ensure consumer safety.

How Do Sunscreens Work to Protect the Skin?

Chemical UV blockers, also known as organic UV filters, work by absorbing UV radiation and converting it into heat, which is then released from the skin. This process prevents UV radiation from penetrating deeper into the skin, reducing the risk of sunburn and skin damage. These compounds contain conjugated pi-electron systems that absorb UV photons. Common examples include benzophenones such as oxybenzone, cinnamates like octinoxate, and avobenzone. Their effectiveness against UVA and UVB radiation depends on their chemical structure and absorption spectrum.

By absorbing UV radiation, chemical blockers reduce the formation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) that can cause DNA damage, leading to premature aging and increasing the risk of skin cancer. However, some chemical UV filters have raised concerns regarding endocrine disruption and environmental impact. Physical UV blockers, also known as inorganic UV filters, work by reflecting and scattering UV radiation away from the skin, preventing it from penetrating and causing damage. These blockers, such as zinc oxide and titanium dioxide, operate through a process known as Mie scattering. The size and refractive index of these particles determine their scattering efficiency, making them effective at reflecting both UVA and UVB radiation.

By reflecting UV radiation, physical blockers prevent the absorption of harmful rays by the skin, reducing the risk of sunburn, premature aging, and skin cancer. These agents are generally considered safe and are often recommended for sensitive skin due to their low risk of allergic reactions.To illustrate the difference between chemical and physical UV blockers, consider the following analogy. Chemical blockers act like a sponge absorbing water, as they absorb UV radiation and dissipate it as heat. In contrast, physical blockers function like a mirror reflecting light, as they reflect UV radiation away from the skin, preventing its absorption.

Both mechanisms effectively prevent skin damage and reduce cancer risk by minimizing exposure to harmful UV radiation. For more detailed diagrams or visuals, consulting scientific articles or educational resources may provide additional illustrations of these mechanisms. However, the provided explanation clarifies the basic principles involved.

Does Sunscreen Prevent Skin Cancer?

Sunscreen plays a vital role in protecting the skin from harmful UV radiation and reducing the risk of skin cancer. Clinical studies, including randomized controlled trials and observational research, provide evidence supporting its effectiveness, while major health organizations advocate for its use as part of a comprehensive sun protection strategy.

Clinical Evidence

Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) provide strong clinical evidence supporting the benefits of sunscreen use. A well-conducted RCT in Australia demonstrated that regular sunscreen application significantly reduced the incidence of squamous cell carcinomas by about 40% compared to discretionary use. Additionally, long-term follow-up indicated a reduced risk of invasive melanoma among participants who used sunscreen daily.Observational studies and meta-analyses have shown mixed results regarding the effectiveness of sunscreen in preventing melanoma and non-melanoma skin cancers. However, many studies support its role in reducing the risk of these cancers, particularly when used as part of a comprehensive sun protection strategy.

Health Organizations Advice

Health organizations widely endorse sunscreen as a critical measure for skin cancer prevention. The World Health Organization emphasizes the importance of sun protection, including sunscreen use, as part of a broader strategy to prevent skin cancer, though specific endorsements regarding melanoma risk reduction are not detailed. The Skin Cancer Foundation strongly recommends broad-spectrum sunscreens with a Sun Protection Factor (SPF) of at least 30 as a key component of skin cancer prevention, highlighting their effectiveness in preventing sunburn and reducing the risk of skin cancers.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) also advocates for sunscreen use as part of a comprehensive sun protection plan, which includes seeking shade, wearing protective clothing, and using sunscreen with SPF 30 or higher. While specific data on melanoma reduction is not explicitly stated, the CDC supports sunscreen for overall skin protection.

In summary, while evidence supports the role of sunscreen in reducing skin cancer risks, its effectiveness can vary depending on the type of cancer and the specific sunscreen ingredients used. Health organizations generally agree that sunscreen is a crucial component of sun protection strategies.

Strolling along the Seashore, 1909 (oil on canvas), Joaquin Sorolla y Bastida (1863-1923) / Museo Sorolla, Madrid, Spain

Common Myths about Sunscreen and Cancer

Many misconceptions surround sunscreen, leading to confusion about its safety and effectiveness. Some believe that natural sunscreens are always safer, while others worry that sunscreen use causes vitamin D deficiency. A common myth suggests that sunscreen is unnecessary indoors or on cloudy days, while another claims that higher SPF products are unsafe. Some also assume that sunscreen is only needed for fair skin. By examining these claims through scientific research and reliable sources, we can better understand the truth behind sunscreen use.

Myth: Natural Sunscreens Are Safer

The misconception that “natural” or DIY sunscreens are safer comes from a preference for natural ingredients and the belief that homemade products contain fewer harmful chemicals. However, this perception overlooks several critical issues. Many DIY sunscreens provide inadequate UV protection. Common ingredients like coconut oil, essential oils, and shea butter block only about 20% of UV rays, offering an SPF equivalent of 1–3, far below the recommended SPF 30 or higher for effective sun protection. Additionally, homemade formulations lack standardization and proper testing, leading to inconsistent and unreliable protection. Even when zinc oxide is included, the formulation may not be effective due to difficulties in evenly distributing the active ingredients without specialized equipment.

Risks of Inadequate UV Protection

Using ineffective sunscreens increases the risk of sunburn and long-term skin damage. A study analyzing internet recipes found that most homemade sunscreens had an SPF under 6, which is insufficient for adequate protection. Some DIY ingredients can also cause skin irritation or allergic reactions, particularly if they are not properly tested for individual skin types. Celine Couteau J Cosmet D Dermatol 2021

Dermatologists strongly advise against using DIY sunscreens due to their lack of efficacy and potential risks. Commercial sunscreens undergo rigorous testing to ensure they provide reliable protection. Experts recommend mineral-based sunscreens with zinc oxide and titanium dioxide for broad-spectrum coverage. The promotion of homemade sunscreens on social media has also raised public health concerns, as many of these recipes do not offer sufficient UV protection, increasing the risk of sunburn and long-term skin damage. Julie Williams Merten Health Commun 2020

In summary, while the idea of using natural ingredients may seem appealing, commercial sunscreens remain a safer and more effective choice for protecting the skin from harmful UV exposure.

Myth: Sunscreen Causes Vitamin D Deficiency

Typical sunscreen use does not significantly reduce vitamin D synthesis in most individuals. Here’s why and how you can balance sun protection with maintaining adequate vitamin D levels.

Vitamin D production in the skin is initiated by UVB rays, which make up only about 5% of the sun’s rays. While sunscreen blocks UVB rays, studies have shown that typical sunscreen use does not lead to lower vitamin D levels in real-life settings. Although sunscreen can theoretically reduce vitamin D production by blocking UVB rays, practical studies indicate that this effect is minimal. Additionally, sunscreen helps prevent the degradation of vitamin D in the skin, potentially maintaining stable levels. R E Neale Br J Dermatol 2019

Photo from Skin Science Authority

To balance sun protection and vitamin D levels, it is important to include dietary sources of vitamin D in your diet. Foods such as fatty fish, egg yolks, beef liver, and fortified products like milk, orange juice, and cereals are good sources. If necessary, vitamin D supplements can be taken, particularly for individuals with a deficiency, during the winter months, or for those with limited sun exposure.While sunscreen is essential for preventing skin damage, brief periods of unprotected sun exposure, such as a few minutes on the arms and legs, can help boost vitamin D levels.

However, this should not be relied upon as the primary source of vitamin D. According to British Association of Dermatologists, typical sunscreen use does not significantly impact vitamin D synthesis, and maintaining adequate vitamin D levels can be achieved through a balanced diet and supplements. It is essential to prioritize sun protection to prevent skin damage and reduce the risks of skin-related health issues.

Myth: You Don’t Need Sunscreen Indoors or on Cloudy Days

UVA rays can penetrate through various barriers, including clouds and windows, making sunscreen use important even on overcast days or indoors.While clouds can reduce UV radiation, they do not block it entirely. Up to 80% of UVA rays can pass through clouds, especially light clouds, which offer minimal protection. This means that significant UV exposure is still possible on cloudy days, increasing the risk of sunburn and skin damage.

UVA rays can also penetrate through glass windows, although the extent varies depending on the type of glass. Standard residential and commercial window glass blocks UVB but allows some UVA to pass through. This can lead to cumulative UV exposure over time, contributing to premature skin aging and potentially increasing the risk of skin damage.Everyday activities can also expose individuals to UVA rays. Drivers, for example, are exposed to UVA rays through side and rear windows, which can lead to increased skin damage and higher cancer risk on the side of the body closest to the window.

This is particularly concerning for individuals who spend a lot of time driving. Similarly, people who work near windows or in glass greenhouses are at risk of cumulative UVA exposure, which can contribute to skin damage over time.Even on cloudy days, it is essential to apply sunscreen to protect against UVA rays that can penetrate through clouds. This is crucial for preventing sunburn and reducing long-term skin damage.UVA rays can penetrate both clouds and windows, making sunscreen use important even on overcast days or indoors. Regular application of sunscreen with broad-spectrum protection is recommended to mitigate these risks.

Sun with human face rising – Splendor Solis (1582), f.33v – BL Harley MS 3469

Myth: Higher SPF Sunscreens Are Unsafe

UVA rays can penetrate through various barriers, including clouds and windows, making sunscreen use important even on overcast days or indoors.While clouds can reduce UV radiation, they do not block it entirely. Up to 80% of UVA rays can pass through clouds, especially light clouds, which offer minimal protection. This means that significant UV exposure is still possible on cloudy days, increasing the risk of sunburn and skin damage.UVA rays can also penetrate through glass windows, although the extent varies depending on the type of glass.

Standard residential and commercial window glass blocks UVB but allows some UVA to pass through. This can lead to cumulative UV exposure over time, contributing to premature skin aging and potentially increasing the risk of skin damage.Everyday activities can also expose individuals to UVA rays. Drivers, for example, are exposed to UVA rays through side and rear windows, which can lead to increased skin damage and higher cancer risk on the side of the body closest to the window.

This is particularly concerning for individuals who spend a lot of time driving. Similarly, people who work near windows or in glass greenhouses are at risk of cumulative UVA exposure, which can contribute to skin damage over time. Sonia Santander Ballestín Appl. Sci. 2023 

Even on cloudy days, it is essential to apply sunscreen to protect against UVA rays that can penetrate through clouds. This is crucial for preventing sunburn and reducing long-term skin damage.In summary, UVA rays can penetrate both clouds and windows, making sunscreen use important even on overcast days or indoors. Regular application of sunscreen with broad-spectrum protection is recommended to mitigate these risks.

Myth: Sunscreen Is Only for Fair Skin

The misconception that people with darker skin tones don’t need sunscreen overlooks the potential for UV exposure to cause skin damage and cancer in all skin types.

While melanin provides some natural protection against UV radiation, offering an estimated SPF of about 13, it is insufficient for preventing all types of skin damage. Melanin may not protect as effectively against UVA rays, which contribute to photoaging and skin cancer. Additionally, UV exposure can worsen pigmentary disorders such as melasma and discoid lupus erythematosus, which are common in individuals with darker skin tones. Sunscreen is crucial for managing these conditions.

Although the incidence of skin cancer is lower in individuals with darker skin tones, they are more likely to be diagnosed with melanoma at a later stage, which results in a worse prognosis. This emphasizes the importance of sun protection and early detection. There is also a disparity in sunscreen counseling and skin cancer diagnosis among individuals with darker skin tones. Dermatologists often discuss sunscreen use less with these patients, despite the need for sun protection to prevent skin damage and cancer.

Some individuals with darker skin tones may avoid sunscreen due to cosmetic concerns, such as the white residue left by physical sunscreens. However, tinted sunscreens and chemical sunscreens can provide effective protection without these aesthetic drawbacks. Hannah Song Int J Womens Dermatol 2020

In summary, while melanin offers some natural protection, it is insufficient for preventing all types of skin damage and cancer. Sunscreen use is essential for individuals of all skin tones to ensure adequate protection against UV radiation and reduce the risk of skin damage and cancer.

You Can Also Read Hugh Jackman and Skin Cancer by OncoDaily

How to Choose Safe and Effective Sunscreens

Here are some tips for selecting sunscreen products, along with advice on avoiding unregulated claims and suggestions for dermatologist-recommended brands:

• Broad-Spectrum Protection: Ensure the sunscreen offers broad-spectrum protection, meaning it guards against both UVA and UVB rays. This is crucial for preventing premature aging and skin cancer12.
• SPF 30 or Higher: Choose a sunscreen with an SPF of at least 30. This provides adequate protection against UVB rays, blocking about 97% of them56.
• Water Resistance: If you plan to be in water or sweat heavily, select a water-resistant sunscreen. However, remember to reapply every two hours or after swimming or sweating52.
• Skin Type Considerations: For sensitive skin, opt for physical sunscreens like zinc oxide or titanium dioxide, which are less likely to cause irritation53.
• Avoid Unregulated Claims: Be cautious of products making unverified claims about their effectiveness or ingredients. Look for products from reputable brands and check for regulatory compliance.

While specific brands are not mentioned in the search results, dermatologists generally recommend products from well-known companies that adhere to FDA guidelines and offer broad-spectrum protection.

Proper Application of Sunscreen for Maximum Protection

Step 1: Apply Sunscreen Correctly

To ensure full coverage, apply about 1 ounce (30 ml) of sunscreen to cover your entire body, which is roughly the amount that fits in a shot glass. For the face, use about a teaspoon. It’s important to apply sunscreen 15-30 minutes before going outside to allow it to absorb fully. Make sure to rub the sunscreen thoroughly into all exposed skin areas, including often-missed spots like the ears, back of the neck, tops of the feet, and hands.

Step 2: Reapply Sunscreen

Reapply sunscreen every two hours or immediately after swimming or sweating to maintain effective protection. Consistency is key, so make sunscreen application a regular part of your daily routine, even on cloudy days when UV rays can still penetrate the clouds.

Step 3: Additional Tips

Apply sunscreen as the last step in your skincare routine, after moisturizer, to ensure it’s effective. For hard-to-reach areas like your back, use a spray sunscreen or ask someone to help apply it. Don’t forget to protect your lips with a lip balm that contains SPF.

Are All High-Quality Sunscreens Expensive?

Not all good-quality sunscreens are expensive. There are effective options available across various price ranges:

• Affordable Options: Many drugstore sunscreens offer excellent protection at a low cost. These products are often available for a few dollars per ounce and provide reliable SPF protection.
• Mid-Range Options: Mid-priced sunscreens typically offer additional benefits such as mineral formulations, eco-friendly packaging, or specialized skin care ingredients. These products are generally priced between $10 and $30.
• High-End Products: Premium sunscreens often include advanced ingredients for anti-aging, sensitive skin care, or other specialized benefits. These products are typically priced higher, often above $30.

Ultimately, the best sunscreen for you is one that matches your skin type, provides broad-spectrum protection, and fits within your budget.

You Can Also Watch What Does Skin Cancer Look Like?

Environmental Concerns and Reef-Safe Sunscreens

The environmental impact of sunscreen ingredients has raised concerns, particularly regarding the harm caused to coral reefs. Chemical UV filters such as oxybenzone, octinoxate, butylparaben, and 4-methylbenzylidene camphor have been shown to contribute to coral bleaching, disrupt coral reproduction, and damage coral DNA. It is estimated that 14,000 tons of sunscreen enter the oceans annually, further exacerbating these environmental issues. These chemicals can activate latent viral infections in the symbiotic algae that corals rely on for nutrition, leading to bleaching and other harmful effects.

Reef-safe sunscreens typically use mineral UV filters like zinc oxide and titanium dioxide, which are considered safer for marine ecosystems. Unlike chemical filters, mineral-based sunscreens reflect UV rays rather than absorbing them, thus reducing the risk of chemical contamination in waterways. Traditional sunscreens, on the other hand, often contain chemical UV filters that have been linked to coral damage. Although some argue that the environmental impact may be overstated due to low concentrations in natural environments, avoiding these chemicals can still play a role in marine conservation efforts.

To support environmental preservation, it is recommended to choose mineral-based sunscreens with zinc oxide or titanium dioxide as active ingredients. According to the National Ocean Service, avoiding harmful chemicals like oxybenzone and octinoxate is beneficial for protecting coral reefs. Other ways to reduce environmental impact include using UV-protective clothing and seeking shade to minimize sunscreen use.

photo by Colin Baker

In summary, while the impact of sunscreen on coral reefs is a debated topic, choosing reef-safe sunscreens can contribute to marine conservation. Mineral-based sunscreens are generally seen as a safer alternative to traditional chemical sunscreens.

Making Informed Choices for Better Skin Health

Sunscreen plays a crucial role in preventing skin cancer, as UV radiation is the primary cause of skin cancer, responsible for more than 95% of cases in countries like Australia. Regular use of sunscreen can significantly reduce UV exposure, thereby preventing skin damage. Studies have shown that using sunscreen consistently can lower the incidence of both melanoma and non-melanoma skin cancers. For instance, a large Australian study found that daily sunscreen use led to a 40% reduction in the incidence of squamous cell carcinomas. Despite its benefits, some myths claim that sunscreen causes cancer, though scientific evidence does not support this.

Sunscreen products are rigorously tested and approved by regulatory bodies such as the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) in Australia, ensuring they are safe and effective for preventing skin cancer. Sunscreens contain either chemical absorbers or physical reflectors like zinc oxide and titanium dioxide. Both types provide effective protection, though some chemical ingredients have raised environmental concerns. However, their safety for human use is well-established.

To ensure proper protection, it is recommended to use broad-spectrum sunscreens with an SPF of at least 30, which protects against both UVA and UVB rays. Apply sunscreen generously 15-30 minutes before going outside and reapply every two hours, or after swimming or sweating.

Additionally, sunscreen use should be complemented by other sun safety practices, such as seeking shade, wearing protective clothing, and avoiding peak sun hours. Some misinformation continues to circulate, with claims that sunscreen causes cancer, but extensive research has found no credible link between sunscreen use and cancer development. Making sun protection a part of your daily routine, especially during peak sun hours or when outdoors, is essential. By following these evidence-based guidelines and using regulated sunscreen products, you can significantly reduce your risk of skin cancer and safeguard your skin from harmful UV damage. Prioritize sun safety to ensure a healthier, safer life for yourself and your loved ones.

You Can Also Read Does 5G Cause Cancer Myths and Reality by OncoDaily